Thanksgiving Without the All-Nighter

There are two kinds of Thanksgiving cooks: the ones who start Tuesday and the ones who figured out years ago that somebody in this parish will do it better for a fair price. This is for the second group, and for the first group who are ready to convert.

The deadline is the whole decision

Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26. Every option below requires an order placed well before that, and the good ones close early because the kitchen can only hold so many birds. If you are reading this the week of, you are choosing from what is left. If you are reading it now, you have your pick.

The November fruit bowl is already settled. Everything else on the table still has a cutoff attached to it.

Option one: a smoked turkey

The smokehouse route is the most forgiving. You pick up a cooked bird, you reheat it, and you take credit for the rest of the table. Ask three questions before you pay: what size birds they are running this year, whether the pickup window is Wednesday or Thursday morning, and whether reheating instructions come with it. A smoked turkey that sits in a car for two hours is a different meal than one that goes straight into a cooler.

Option two: the full catered spread

Catering makes sense when the head count passes about twelve, or when two families are merging and nobody wants to be the one who cooked. Cajun catering outfits in this area will do the whole plate: turkey or hen, rice dressing, green bean casserole, sweet potatoes, rolls. The trap is ordering sides by the pan without asking how many people a pan actually feeds. Ask for a serving count, not a pan count.

Option three: buy the bird local and cook it yourself

Local birds and farm-raised options go fast, and they cost more than the supermarket loss leader. They also taste like something. Order now, not the week of, and confirm whether it is fresh or frozen, because a frozen bird on Monday is a problem on Thursday. If you are cooking it yourself, the LSU AgCenter food and health pages carry the safe-handling and thawing guidance, and the Louisiana Department of Agriculture lists the certified and farm-direct producers around the state.

Option four: the restaurant table

A growing number of places serve Thanksgiving Day, and for someone alone or working that day it is the best answer on this list. Reservations usually open two to three weeks out and the good times go first.

One thing to do either way

Whatever you order, ask when they need the final head count. That number is what the kitchen actually plans around, and giving it a day early is the difference between a smooth pickup and a line at the door.

The same logic held for the cane syrup in your cabinet and for the pecan candy made here: the good version comes from somebody who planned ahead, and the shelf-stable version is what you get when nobody did.

More from 337 Magazine: The Satsuma Is Not a Clementine · Sweet Deal at the Jockey Lot · Events